Case Summary
This case was a state court challenge to four Wake County House districts in North Carolina’s 2017 plan on the grounds that they violated the state constitution’s prohibition against mid-decade redistricting. It was filed in North Carolina state court on behalf of the N.C. NAACP, Democracy North Carolina, League of Women Voters of North Carolina, A. Philip Randolph Institute of North Carolina, and four individuals (Elaine Okal, Retta Riordan, Cheryl Tung, and Candace Blackley).
When lawmakers altered those districts as part of court-ordered redistricting to cure two racially gerrymandered districts in Wake County, they went beyond what the federal court directed and violated the state constitution. A three-judge panel ruled that the House districts were unconstitutional and directed the General Assembly to adopt a remedial plan during the 2019 legislative session. In February 2019, the legislative defendants filed a notice withdrawing their appeal of that ruling.
Why it's Important
The revised districts breached the state constitution's ban on altering district boundaries mid-decade, and lawmakers exceeded the directives of the federal court by modifying districts that were not necessary to address the issues of racial gerrymandering.
Order Granting Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment
Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment
Legislative Leaders Decline to Appeal Ruling of Unconstitutional Redistricting in Wake County State House Districts
House Districts in Wake County Found Unconstitutional
Voting Rights Advocates Seek New Districts in Wake County for the 2018 Election
Other Related Cases
Texas v. United States
SCSJ represented the Texas NAACP against the state of Texas, in which Texas is seeking federal preclearance for its Congressional, State House and State Senate redistricting plans.
Read More Texas v. United States
Covington v. North Carolina
Southern Coalition for Social Justice successfully challenged 28 of North Carolina's 2011 state house and senate districts as racial gerrymanders in violation of the Equal Protections Clause on behalf of 31 individual voters.
Read More Covington v. North Carolina
Raleigh Wake Citizens Association v. Wake County Board of Elections
After the North Carolina General Assembly passed a local bill in 2013 redistricting the Wake County Board of Education and Board of County Commissioners, SCSJ filed two lawsuits in federal court.
Read More Raleigh Wake Citizens Association v. Wake County Board of Elections
